For Anne Gregory - Short Answers

Home / Textual Notes / Grade 10 / For Anne Gregory

1. What is the central theme of the poem "A Woman's Hair" by William Butler Yeats?

The central theme of the poem is the superficiality of love based solely on physical appearance, particularly focusing on the significance of a woman's hair colour in shaping perceptions of her desirability.

2. How does the speaker address the issue of being loved for one's true self versus superficial attributes?

The speaker expresses scepticism about the possibility of being loved for one's true self alone, suggesting that external characteristics like hair colour often overshadow deeper qualities. This highlights the challenges of finding genuine love amidst societal expectations and superficial standards.

3. What role does the hair colour play in the speaker's contemplation of love?

The hair colour serves as a symbol of superficial attraction, with the speaker questioning whether love based on physical attributes like yellow hair can ever be genuine. The speaker explores the idea of altering one's appearance to test the authenticity of love based on inner qualities.

4. How does the speaker respond to the suggestion of dyeing her hair to attract genuine love?

The speaker entertains the idea of dyeing her hair to test whether she can be loved for her true self rather than her external appearance. However, this suggestion reflects a deeper cynicism about the nature of love and the difficulty of finding genuine affection in a world driven by superficiality.

5. What religious perspective does the speaker reference in the poem?

The speaker references an old religious man who suggests that only God can love someone for their true self rather than superficial attributes. This perspective adds a spiritual dimension to the exploration of genuine love and underscores the speaker's scepticism about human relationships.

6. How does the poem explore societal expectations and beauty standards?

The poem challenges societal expectations and beauty standards by questioning whether genuine love can exist outside the realm of physical appearance. The speaker's contemplation of dyeing her hair reflects the pressure to conform to societal norms and the desire to test the authenticity of love.

7. What does the poem suggest about the nature of romantic relationships?

The poem suggests that romantic relationships are often influenced by superficial factors such as physical appearance, leading to doubts about the authenticity of love. The speaker's contemplation of altering her appearance highlights the challenges of finding genuine affection amidst societal pressures.

8. How does the speaker's tone evolve throughout the poem?

The speaker's tone evolves from contemplative to cynical as she grapples with the idea of being loved for her true self rather than superficial attributes. Initially hopeful about the possibility of genuine love, the speaker becomes increasingly sceptical as she considers societal expectations and religious perspectives.

9. What does the repetition of "love you for yourself alone" signify in the poem?

The repetition of "love you for yourself alone" emphasises the speaker's desire for genuine affection based on inner qualities rather than superficial attributes. However, the repetition also underscores the speaker's scepticism about the possibility of finding such love in a world driven by appearances.

10. How does the poem challenge traditional notions of beauty and desirability?

The poem challenges traditional notions of beauty and desirability by questioning whether genuine love can exist independently of physical appearance. Through the speaker's contemplation of altering her hair colour, the poem explores the complexities of attraction and the difficulty of finding authentic love in a society focused on superficial standards.